Santorini lives up to its reputation — but only if you go at the right time and stay in the right place. Here's what I tell clients who are planning Greece for the first time.
Santorini Is Worth It. With Caveats.
I've planned Greece trips for clients ranging from honeymooners on their first international trip together to seasoned travelers who've been to 50 countries and want to know if Santorini is still worth it. My honest answer: yes, but it requires planning with a clear eye on what the experience actually is. Santorini is one of the most visually stunning places on earth. The caldera views from Oia and Imerovigli are genuinely extraordinary. The cave hotels are architecturally unique in a way that photographs don't fully capture. The sunset from the right terrace with the right glass of Assyrtiko is one of those moments that justifies the whole trip. The crowds in July and August are also genuinely extraordinary — and not in a good way. Here's how to get Santorini right.
When to Go: May, June, or September
The window I recommend most consistently is late May through mid-June. The weather is warm and dry, the sea is swimmable, the caldera doesn't have the August cruise ship situation, and the hotels are at or near their best availability. Everything is open, the energy is good, and you can walk through Oia in the morning without navigating crowds. September is the other excellent window — arguably better for swimming, since the sea has had all summer to warm up, and the summer crowds have thinned meaningfully. The light in September is also remarkable. July and August: the sunsets in Oia become a spectator sport with hundreds of people lining the walls and streets. The caldera fills with cruise ships. I've sent clients in peak summer who loved it, but they went in knowing what they were walking into — and they had hotels that could genuinely insulate them from it. If you want quiet mornings and uncrowded terraces, July and August are the wrong months.
The Hotels Worth the Caldera Premium
Not all caldera-view hotels deliver equally. The cave architecture is everywhere on the caldera, but the quality range is enormous. Grace Hotel Santorini (Auberge Resorts Collection) is my most consistent recommendation for clients who want a full-service luxury experience with real infrastructure — multiple pools, a serious spa, an excellent restaurant, and caldera views that are among the best on the island. Auberge properties consistently deliver on service in a way that some of the smaller boutique hotels don't. Astarte Suites is what I recommend for couples who want extreme privacy and architecture — intimate, stunning, and not for anyone who needs nightlife within walking distance. Canaves Oia Epitome is the right answer for clients who want the Oia village experience with genuine luxury service. The main Canaves Oia property is also excellent and tends to have better availability. For clients who want something outside the caldera experience: Vedema Resort in the village of Megalochori is an extraordinary collection of manor houses and cave spaces in a working winery — completely different from the cliff-edge hotels and genuinely one of the most beautiful properties in Greece.
Should You Combine Santorini With Mykonos?
This is the most common Greece question I get, and the answer depends entirely on what you want. Mykonos and Santorini are frequently paired as a two-island combination, and the ferry route between them is well-established. Mykonos is a party island with world-class beach clubs, excellent restaurants, and a town that is genuinely fun to explore. It's loud, social, and expensive. If that's what you're after, it pairs beautifully with the quieter, more romantic character of Santorini. If you want a quieter Greece trip — more scenery, more history, less nightlife — I'd steer you away from Mykonos and toward the combination of Santorini with Naxos or Folegandros. Naxos in particular is dramatically underrated: larger than Santorini, with long sandy beaches, a medieval hilltop kastro, and none of the crowds. It's one of my personal favorite Aegean islands.
Athens: Don't Skip It
The most common itinerary mistake I see on Greece trips is treating Athens as a transit city. Two nights in Athens at the beginning of a Santorini trip is the right structure — the Acropolis in the early morning before the crowds arrive, dinner in Monastiraki or Kolonaki, a walk through the Plaka. Athens has a real food scene and a hotel landscape that has gotten dramatically better over the last five years. The Grande Bretagne on Syntagma Square is the classic — a historic property with one of the best rooftop views in the city. For something more boutique, the NEW Hotel and the Hotel Grande Bretagne have both undergone serious renovations and are worth the conversation.
How I Build Greece Itineraries
Greece trips work best when they're built around a clear sequence: Athens first for context and culture, then island time for relaxation. The specific islands depend on what you want from the trip — I ask every Greece client the same question: do you want beaches, history, scenery, or nightlife? The answer shapes everything. I work with a network of preferred partner hotels throughout Greece and regularly secure upgrades, resort credits, and room category improvements that aren't available through OTAs. If you're planning a Greece trip and want to talk through the right structure for your dates and priorities, I'd love to hear from you.
Start Planning Your Greece TripRelated Reading
The Edited Traveler
Let’s plan your trip
Tell me where you want to go, who is traveling and what matters most. I’ll come back with hand-picked hotels, VIP perks where available (often upgrades, daily breakfast and hotel credits) and a plan built around how you like to travel.
Not ready yet? Get the free VIP hotel perks guide. Prefer email? Write to Jared@TheEditedTraveler.com.
Jared Goldstein, Founder and Lead Advisor, Los Angeles.